Professional Contract Design for Outsourcing Success
Contract Design for Outsourcing Relationships
Development of customized, legally compliant, and flexible contract solutions that protect your interests and enable successful outsourcing relationships.
- ✓Legally compliant contract templates and clauses
- ✓Risk-focused contract design and negotiation support
- ✓Comprehensive SLA and exit strategy development
- ✓Regulatory compliance and continuous optimization
Your strategic success starts here
Our clients trust our expertise in digital transformation, compliance, and risk management
30 Minutes • Non-binding • Immediately available
For optimal preparation of your strategy session:
- Your strategic goals and objectives
- Desired business outcomes and ROI
- Steps already taken
Or contact us directly:
Certifications, Partners and more...
Professional Contract Design for Outsourcing Relationships
Why Choose ADVISORI?
- Deep expertise in regulatory compliance and contract law
- Proven track record in complex outsourcing negotiations
- Practical, business-focused approach to contract design
- Comprehensive support from strategy to implementation
⚠
Expert Insight
The most successful outsourcing relationships are built on contracts that balance legal protection with operational flexibility. Invest time in comprehensive contract design to avoid costly disputes and ensure long-term success.
ADVISORI in Numbers
11+
Years of Experience
120+
Employees
520+
Projects
We follow a systematic, risk-focused methodology that combines legal expertise with practical business understanding to deliver contract solutions that protect your interests and enable successful outsourcing relationships.
Our Approach:
Comprehensive requirements analysis and risk assessment
Strategic contract structure development
Detailed clause elaboration and legal review
Negotiation support and strategy development
Implementation support and continuous optimization
"ADVISORI's support in redesigning our outsourcing contracts not only provided us with legal certainty but also significantly improved operational collaboration with our service providers. Particularly valuable was the combination of legal expertise and practical understanding of our business requirements."
Sarah Richter
Head of Information Security, Cyber Security
Expertise & Experience:
10+ years of experience, CISA, CISM, Lead Auditor, DORA, NIS2, BCM, Cyber and Information Security
Our Services
We offer you tailored solutions for your digital transformation
Contract Template Development
Creation of standardized, modular contract templates for various outsourcing scenarios with flexibly adaptable components.
- Industry-specific contract frameworks
- Modular clause libraries
- Regulatory compliance integration
SLA Design & Performance Management
Development of effective service level agreements with clear metrics, measurement procedures, and enforcement mechanisms.
- Business-aligned SLA metrics
- Performance monitoring frameworks
- Incentive and penalty structures
Exit Strategy & Transition Planning
Comprehensive exit management clauses and transition planning to minimize risks and ensure smooth service handover.
- Exit scenario planning
- Data migration frameworks
- Knowledge transfer protocols
Contract Negotiation Support
Expert support in contract negotiations with development of effective strategies and tactics for various scenarios.
- Negotiation strategy development
- Risk position analysis
- Active negotiation participation
Regulatory Compliance Integration
Integration of regulatory requirements into contract frameworks with continuous adaptation to new supervisory regulations.
- Compliance requirement mapping
- Audit rights specification
- Regulatory change management
Contract Documentation & Management
Structured documentation of complex contract frameworks for internal stakeholders, governance bodies, and supervisory authorities.
- Comprehensive contract documentation
- Version control and change tracking
- Stakeholder communication materials
Looking for a complete overview of all our services?
View Complete Service OverviewOur Areas of Expertise in Information Security
Discover our specialized areas of information security
Frequently Asked Questions about Contract Design for Outsourcing Relationships
What elements are essential for legally compliant outsourcing contracts?
Legally compliant outsourcing contracts must contain numerous specific elements to fulfill both regulatory requirements and adequately protect business interests. The particular challenge lies in combining legal precision with practical applicability. A professionally designed outsourcing contract considers not only current legal requirements but also anticipates potential risks and developments in the business relationship. The following core elements are indispensable and should be elaborated with particular care in every outsourcing contract.
📋 Precise Service Description:
•
Detailed, unambiguous definition of the scope of services with clear delineation of responsibilities for both parties.
•
Concrete description of deliverables, work results, and expected quality standards.
•
Specification of handover and acceptance processes with specific criteria and timelines.
•
Clear regulations on the involvement of subcontractors and their responsibilities.
•
Defined processes for service changes and adjustments during the contract term.
⚖ ️ Compliance and Regulatory Requirements:
•
Integration of all regulatory requirements relevant to the specific industry (e.g., MaRisk, BAIT, DORA).
•
Specification of control, access, and audit rights of the outsourcing company and supervisory authorities.
•
Explicit obligations to comply with data protection regulations with concrete technical and organizational measures.
•
Regulations on information security with minimum standards and certification requirements.
•
Obligation to cooperate with official inquiries and supervisory audits.
📊 Service Level Agreements (SLAs):
•
Definition of measurable, relevant performance indicators with clear metrics and target values.
•
Specification of measurement procedures, measurement intervals, and reporting formats for performance monitoring.
•
Implementation of a graduated escalation process for SLA violations with specific contact persons and time specifications.
•
Clear consequences for non-compliance, from contractual penalties to extraordinary termination rights.
•
Incentive mechanisms for exceeding targets and continuous improvement of service quality.
🔄 Contract Term and Termination Provisions:
•
Clear definition of the contract term with precise regulations on extensions and notice periods.
•
Detailed regulations for ordinary and extraordinary termination rights with specific termination grounds.
•
Comprehensive exit management clauses with regulations on service handover, data migration, and knowledge transfer.
•
Specification of support obligations of the service provider after contract termination with concrete scope and remuneration.
•
Regulations on handling assets, rights, and confidential information after contract end.
💼 Liability and Risk Allocation:
•
Balanced liability regulations with appropriate liability limitations and exclusions.
•
Concrete regulations on insurance obligations of the service provider with minimum coverage amounts and proof obligations.
•
Precise indemnification clauses for third-party claims, particularly for intellectual property violations or data protection breaches.
•
Clear allocation of responsibilities in case of data loss, security incidents, or business interruptions.
•
Specific regulations for force majeure events with notification obligations and mitigation measures.
How do you develop a customized contract structure for different outsourcing scenarios?
Developing customized contract structures for outsourcing requires a systematic, risk-focused approach that considers the specific characteristics and requirements of each outsourcing scenario. Unlike standard contracts, this involves precisely aligning contractual provisions with the specific operational, legal, and strategic circumstances of the respective outsourcing. This customized approach forms the foundation for a successful, legally compliant, and value-creating outsourcing relationship.
🔍 Systematic Analysis Phase:
•
Conducting a comprehensive risk analysis as the basis for the contract structure with identification of specific risk areas of the outsourcing.
•
Evaluation of regulatory requirements for the specific outsourcing depending on industry, criticality, and data categories.
•
Analysis of the strategic importance of the outsourcing for the company and derivation of corresponding contractual protection mechanisms.
•
Assessment of operational requirements for service delivery, including integration into existing processes and systems.
•
Evaluation of market position and negotiating power of both parties as a basis for realistic contract negotiation goals.
📑 Modular Contract Architecture:
•
Development of a multi-layered contract structure with master agreement and specific service schedules or annexes.
•
Implementation of a Master Service Agreement (MSA) for overarching regulations such as governance, compliance, and legal principles.
•
Creation of specific Service Schedules or Statements of Work (SoW) for detailed service descriptions of individual outsourcing areas.
•
Integration of dedicated annexes for cross-cutting topics such as data protection, information security, or business continuity.
•
Development of customized SLA annexes with service-specific metrics, measurement procedures, and consequences.
⚖ ️ Differentiation by Outsourcing Types:
•
IT Outsourcing: Focus on technical specifications, interface definitions, change management, and technology evolution.
•
Business Process Outsourcing: Emphasis on end-to-end process continuity, capacity flexibility, and cultural aspects.
•
Critical Core Functions: Implementation of particularly robust control, monitoring, and exit mechanisms according to regulatory requirements.
•
Cloud Services: Integration of cloud-specific aspects such as multi-tenancy, data localization, and continuous updates/upgrades.
•
Nearshore/Offshore Scenarios: Consideration of international legal issues, cultural differences, and special communication structures.
🔄 Flexibility Mechanisms and Scalability:
•
Implementation of structured change request processes with defined decision paths and approval levels.
•
Integration of benchmarking and market testing clauses for continuous competitiveness review.
•
Development of contract adjustment mechanisms for technological developments, business changes, or regulatory modifications.
•
Specification of innovation obligations and continuous improvement processes with concrete goals and incentives.
•
Implementation of scaling mechanisms for service scope, volume, and capacities.
🤝 Practical Implementation and Governance:
•
Development of a Contract Playbook with standardized formulations, fallback positions, and negotiation guidelines.
•
Establishment of a clearly defined governance framework with roles, responsibilities, and communication structures.
•
Integration of mechanisms for continuous contract optimization and adjustment over the lifecycle.
•
Establishment of a structured documentation system with clear version control and change tracking.
•
Development of compliance checklists to ensure complete consideration of all regulatory requirements.
What legal specifics must be considered when designing cloud service contracts?
Designing cloud service contracts requires special legal attention, as traditional outsourcing contract patterns often do not adequately address the specific characteristics and risks of cloud services. The standardization of cloud offerings, the multi-tier service provider structure, data and compliance issues, and continuous update cycles present special challenges that must be specifically addressed in contract design. Professional cloud contract design considers these specifics and creates a framework that provides both legal certainty and the necessary flexibility to utilize cloud advantages.
🔄 Handling Standard Contracts and Limited Negotiating Power:
•
Development of risk-focused prioritization for contract negotiations, as cloud providers often show limited willingness to adapt.
•
Identification and focus on indispensable regulatory requirements and critical business risks in negotiations.
•
Targeted supplementation of standard contracts through side letters or additional agreements for company-specific requirements.
•
Use of multi-provider strategies for risk diversification and strengthening negotiating position.
•
Careful documentation of risk assessment and acceptance of remaining risks for non-negotiable clauses.
🌐 Data Localization and International Data Flows:
•
Implementation of precise contractual regulations on data storage location with concrete specifications of data center locations.
•
Integration of appropriate safeguards for international data transfers according to GDPR, such as Standard Contractual Clauses or Binding Corporate Rules.
•
Specification of transparency and information obligations for changes in data processing locations or subcontractors.
•
Consideration of industry-specific data localization requirements, especially in the financial sector, healthcare, and public sector.
•
Implementation of exit strategies in case of legal changes that restrict or make international data transfers impossible.
🔍 Transparency and Control in Multi-Tier Service Provider Relationships:
•
Contractual assurance of appropriate transparency across the entire service provider chain (sub-processors).
•
Specification of approval processes or at least information obligations for changes in the subcontractor structure.
•
Integration of audit and control rights covering the entire service provider chain with practicable implementation mechanisms.
•
Implementation of due diligence obligations of the cloud provider in selecting and monitoring subcontractors.
•
Establishment of clear liability and responsibility regulations for actions and omissions of subcontractors.
📊 Service Continuity and Performance Management:
•
Development of cloud-specific SLAs with metrics such as availability, latency, response times, and recovery times.
•
Implementation of appropriate compensation mechanisms for SLA violations that correspond to actual business impacts.
•
Specification of regulations for planned maintenance windows with appropriate lead times and minimization of operational impacts.
•
Integration of business continuity and disaster recovery obligations with concrete RPOs and RTOs.
•
Agreement on monitoring and reporting mechanisms for continuous monitoring of service quality.
🔒 Information Security and Compliance:
•
Definition of cloud-specific security requirements considering shared responsibility models of different cloud types (IaaS, PaaS, SaaS).
•
Specification of certification requirements (e.g., ISO 27001, SOC 2, C5) and processes for regular compliance verification.
•
Integration of specific incident response obligations with clear reporting channels, deadlines, and support obligations.
•
Agreement on compliance evidence and regular security reports without violating multi-tenant architecture.
•
Development of mechanisms for continuous adaptation of security requirements to new threats and regulatory developments.
How do you design effective service descriptions and SLAs for outsourcing contracts?
Designing precise service descriptions and effective Service Level Agreements (SLAs) is a critical success factor for outsourcing relationships. They form the basis for a common understanding of expected performance, create transparency, and enable objective evaluation of service provider performance. The particular challenge lies in finding a balanced equilibrium: on one hand, requirements must be sufficiently detailed and measurable; on the other hand, they must not become too rigid or unrealistic. A professional approach combines technical precision with business relevance and creates both clarity and the necessary flexibility for long-term successful collaboration.
📋 Basic Principles of Effective Service Descriptions:
•
Focus on clearly defined results and outcomes rather than pure activity descriptions.
•
Use of precise, unambiguous terminology with clear definitions of central terms to avoid interpretation gaps.
•
Structuring into logical, delineated service components with clear interfaces and responsibilities.
•
Balanced level of detail: sufficiently specific for clarity, but not over-specified to maintain necessary flexibility.
•
Integration of graphical elements such as process diagrams, RACI matrices, and interface descriptions to visualize complex relationships.
🎯 Development of Relevant and Measurable SLA Metrics:
•
Identification of business-critical aspects of the outsourced service as the basis for SLA definition.
•
Development of a balanced set of metrics covering various performance dimensions (availability, response time, quality, capacity).
•
Specification of SMART indicators (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) with clear measurement procedures.
•
Differentiation between different priority levels and service levels depending on business criticality.
•
Consideration of the end-to-end perspective with focus on actual business impacts rather than isolated technical metrics.
📊 Monitoring, Reporting, and Governance:
•
Establishment of clear processes and responsibilities for continuous measurement and documentation of SLA metrics.
•
Definition of standardized reporting formats with different levels of detail for various stakeholder groups.
•
Specification of regular review cycles and governance meetings for evaluating performance and addressing deviations.
•
Implementation of a graduated escalation process with clear triggers, contact persons, and timeframes.
•
Establishment of mechanisms for continuous improvement with joint analysis of trends and root causes.
⚖ ️ Consequences and Incentive Structures:
•
Development of a graduated system of consequences for SLA violations, proportional to the severity and frequency of deviations.
•
Implementation of financial penalties that provide an effective incentive without being prohibitive or straining the relationship.
•
Design of service credits as the primary mechanism for moderate SLA violations with direct offset against invoices.
•
Integration of earn-back mechanisms that allow remediation through exceeded SLAs in subsequent periods.
•
Development of positive incentive systems for exceeding targets or continuous improvement of service quality.
🔄 Flexibility and Scalability:
•
Implementation of a structured SLA review process with defined intervals for adaptation to changed business requirements.
•
Specification of mechanisms for rapid adjustment in exceptional business situations or unforeseen events.
•
Integration of continuous improvement goals with gradual increase of requirements over the contract term.
•
Development of mechanisms for benchmarking against market standards with optional adjustment obligations.
•
Consideration of the introduction phase with adapted requirements and gradual increase to full service level.
How do you design effective exit strategies in outsourcing contracts?
Designing effective exit strategies is a critical component of professional outsourcing contracts. A well-thought-out exit strategy minimizes risks and costs when terminating the outsourcing relationship and enables a smooth transition to alternative solutions.
🔄 Comprehensive Exit Scenarios and Planning:
•
Differentiated consideration of various exit scenarios: regular contract termination, early termination, force majeure, insolvency of the service provider.
•
Development of a structured exit plan with clearly defined phases, milestones, and responsibilities.
•
Specification of early trigger points and warning signals that initiate exit preparations.
•
Integration of exit impact assessments to evaluate operational, financial, and regulatory impacts.
•
Establishment of an exit governance model with clear decision paths and escalation mechanisms.
📦 Data and Asset Migration:
•
Precise definition of data extraction and migration processes with concrete formats and handover points.
•
Specification of clear ownership rights and usage rights for data, software, and documentation.
•
Obligation of the service provider to provide structured data in standardized formats.
•
Definition of data quality standards for migration with validation processes.
•
Regulations on secure deletion of data after successful migration with corresponding proof obligations.
🧠 Knowledge Transfer and Know-how Preservation:
•
Establishment of continuous knowledge transfer processes throughout the entire contract term.
•
Contractual obligation for comprehensive documentation of all processes, systems, and configurations.
•
Specification of training and onboarding obligations for successor teams.
•
Regulations on availability and participation of key personnel during the transition phase.
•
Development of knowledge management systems for structured capture of knowledge.
What role do liability provisions play in outsourcing contracts?
Liability provisions in outsourcing contracts form a central component of contractual risk allocation and are crucial for the viability of the outsourcing relationship. A differentiated, risk-appropriate liability design is clearly superior to a blanket approach.
⚖ ️ Basic Structures of Contractual Liability Concepts:
•
Development of a differentiated liability concept with graduated regimes for different scenarios.
•
Precise definition of liability triggers and claim prerequisites for various contract risks.
•
Implementation of separate liability regulations for particularly damage-prone areas.
•
Specification of clear burden of proof distributions and proof obligations when asserting claims.
•
Establishment of a graduated escalation and conflict resolution mechanism for liability cases.
🛡 ️ Differentiated Liability Limitations and Exclusions:
•
Implementation of appropriate, risk-adequate liability limitations based on economic significance.
•
Differentiation between different types of damage with different liability limits.
•
Specification of specific exceptions to liability limitations for particularly serious cases.
•
Development of area-specific liability limits for different service components.
•
Implementation of deductibles and co-payments to promote risk prevention.
📊 Insurance and Financial Security Mechanisms:
•
Specification of concrete insurance obligations of the service provider with minimum coverage amounts.
•
Implementation of proof obligations for insurance coverage with regular reviews.
•
Integration of direct claims against the service provider's insurers.
•
Development of alternative security mechanisms such as bank guarantees or escrow accounts.
•
Specification of notification obligations for changes in insurance coverage.
How do you integrate information security requirements into outsourcing contracts?
Integrating information security requirements into outsourcing contracts is a critical success factor for secure outsourcing relationships in light of increasing cybersecurity risks. An effective contractual information security framework must address both current and future threats.
🔒 Basic Security Architecture and Governance:
•
Development of a comprehensive Information Security Requirements Catalog as a binding contractual basis.
•
Precise definition of security responsibilities in a RACI model.
•
Implementation of a security governance framework with defined roles and escalation paths.
•
Specification of quantifiable security metrics for objective measurement of security level.
•
Establishment of regular security review meetings for continuous monitoring.
🔍 Risk Management and Compliance Requirements:
•
Implementation of a continuous, risk-based security assessment process.
•
Obligation to comply with relevant security standards such as ISO 27001 or NIST.
•
Specification of specific requirements for compliance with industry-specific regulations.
•
Integration of requirements for supply chain security management.
•
Obligation to continuously monitor regulatory changes in the security area.
🛡 ️ Technical Security Measures and Controls:
•
Detailed specification of minimum requirements for technical protective measures.
•
Specification of concrete requirements for detective controls such as security monitoring.
•
Definition of requirements for reactive security measures such as incident response.
•
Specification of security requirements for different system environments.
•
Integration of specific security requirements for modern technologies such as cloud services.
How can innovation incentives be anchored in long-term outsourcing contracts?
Anchoring effective innovation incentives in long-term outsourcing contracts is a central challenge of modern contract design. A well-thought-out contractual innovation framework creates the foundation for a future-proof outsourcing relationship that fulfills both current and future requirements.
🎯 Strategic Innovation Goals and Governance:
•
Establishment of a dedicated Innovation Framework with clear definitions and responsibilities.
•
Implementation of a Joint Innovation Committee with defined decision-making authority.
•
Development of a joint Innovation Roadmap with short- and long-term goals.
•
Specification of Innovation KPIs for objective evaluation of innovation progress.
•
Integration of market and technology radar processes to identify innovation trends.
💰 Commercial Incentive Structures for Innovation:
•
Implementation of a gain-sharing model for demonstrable efficiency improvements through innovations.
•
Development of an Innovation Fund with dedicated budget for pilot projects.
•
Integration of Innovation KPIs into the commercial model with bonus-malus mechanisms.
•
Design of flexible pricing models for innovative services with success-based remuneration.
•
Implementation of open book approaches for innovation initiatives with transparent cost evaluation.
🚀 Processes and Methods for Systematic Innovation:
•
Establishment of a structured Innovation Process from idea generation to implementation.
•
Specification of agile development methods for innovation initiatives with iterative feedback loops.
•
Integration of regular Innovation Workshops and design thinking sessions.
•
Implementation of proof-of-concept projects with simplified approval processes.
•
Development of structured knowledge management for innovations with documentation of best practices.
What contractual measures help in managing subcontractors in outsourcing relationships?
Effective contractual management of subcontractors is a central success factor in modern outsourcing management. Due to increasing specialization and globalization of supply chains, outsourcing relationships are becoming increasingly complex and often include multi-tier service provider chains. This significantly increases challenges for transparency, control, and compliance.
🔍 Transparency and Approval Processes:
•
Implementation of clear transparency obligations with complete disclosure of all subcontractors and their service shares.
•
Establishment of graduated approval processes with different requirements depending on the criticality of the outsourced function.
•
Specification of specific criteria for the admissibility of subcontractors (e.g., certifications, locations, minimum size).
•
Integration of preliminary reviews (due diligence) of new subcontractors with defined review areas and minimum standards.
•
Development of structured change management processes for changes in the subcontractor structure.
📝 Contractual Pass-Through and Control Rights:
•
Implementation of direct contractual pass-through rights to subcontractors for critical functions and services.
•
Specification of concrete audit, control, and inspection rights along the entire supply chain.
•
Agreement on information, disclosure, and documentation obligations regarding subcontractor management.
•
Integration of binding minimum requirements for back-to-back contracts between main service provider and subcontractors.
•
Establishment of third-party beneficiary contract clauses in favor of the outsourcing company in subcontractor contracts.
⚖ ️ Compliance and Responsibility Distribution:
•
Clear contractual regulation of the primary responsibility of the main service provider for all subcontractor services.
•
Specification of comprehensive compliance obligations for the entire supply chain, especially in regulated areas.
•
Implementation of specific liability and indemnification regulations for subcontractor failures.
•
Integration of certification and proof obligations for compliance with regulatory requirements.
•
Development of special termination rights for serious compliance violations at the subcontractor level.
🚨 Risk Management and Contingency Plans:
•
Obligation to develop and regularly review risk assessments for the subcontractor structure.
•
Specification of concrete emergency and fallback concepts for critical subcontractor services.
•
Establishment of graduated escalation and intervention mechanisms for service disruptions at the subcontractor level.
•
Implementation of monitoring and early warning systems for operational and financial risks with important subcontractors.
•
Agreement on replacement and transition scenarios for the failure of essential subcontractors.
📊 Reporting and Performance Management:
•
Development of structured subcontractor reporting with defined metrics and reporting intervals.
•
Implementation of consistent performance management across all levels of the supply chain.
•
Specification of quality and performance indicators (KPIs) for subcontractor services with clear thresholds.
•
Establishment of regular service review meetings with inclusion of essential subcontractors.
•
Integration of incentives and sanction mechanisms for the performance of subcontractors.
How should Service Level Agreements (SLAs) be designed to be legally compliant?
Legally compliant design of Service Level Agreements (SLAs) is a decisive factor for the success of outsourcing relationships. Professionally developed SLAs create clear performance expectations, enable objective performance measurement, and provide effective enforcement mechanisms for deficiencies. The particular challenge lies in combining technical precision, legal enforceability, and practical applicability.
📊 Precise Metric Definition and Measurement Procedures:
•
Development of clearly defined, measurable, and objectively verifiable performance metrics for all critical service aspects.
•
Specification of precise measurement points, intervals, and procedures with clear data sources and calculation methods.
•
Definition of threshold values with clear tolerance ranges and differentiation between different error classes.
•
Implementation of statistically valid sampling and survey procedures for performance measurement.
•
Specification of data validation and quality assurance processes to avoid measurement errors and manipulation.
⚖ ️ Legal Integration and Enforceability:
•
Clear legal integration of SLAs into the contract structure with unambiguous legal binding effect.
•
Definition of precise consequences for SLA violations with graduated, appropriate legal consequences.
•
Implementation of a legally compliant service credit system with clear calculation formulas and billing modalities.
•
Specification of specific rights for repeated or serious SLA violations (special termination rights, damages).
•
Integration of regulations on burden of proof distribution and documentation obligations for SLA violations.
🔧 Operationalization and Management:
•
Establishment of a structured SLA management process with clear roles, responsibilities, and escalation paths.
•
Implementation of automated monitoring and reporting systems for continuous SLA monitoring.
•
Specification of standardized reporting formats with different levels of detail for different stakeholders.
•
Establishment of regular SLA review meetings with clearly defined participants, agenda, and decision-making authority.
•
Development of root cause analysis processes for systematic investigation of SLA violations.
🔄 Flexibility and Adaptability:
•
Implementation of structured SLA adjustment processes for changed business requirements or environmental conditions.
•
Specification of transition and phase-in regulations for the introduction of new services or SLAs.
•
Development of mechanisms for temporary SLA adjustment in exceptional situations (e.g., force majeure).
•
Integration of continuous improvement requirements with gradual increase of SLA targets over the contract term.
•
Implementation of benchmarking mechanisms for market-appropriate adjustment of SLAs during the contract term.
💼 Business Relevance and End-to-End Perspective:
•
Alignment of SLAs with concrete business requirements and goals with clear reference to customer experience and value creation.
•
Implementation of an end-to-end perspective that considers the entire service chain from provider to end user.
•
Specification of different service levels for different business processes based on their criticality.
•
Integration of user-centric metrics that measure actual service quality from the user perspective.
•
Linking of SLAs with business impact analyses for prioritization in resource conflicts or crisis situations.
What core elements should compliance clauses contain in outsourcing contracts?
Effective compliance clauses in outsourcing contracts are crucial for fulfilling regulatory requirements and minimizing legal risks. Especially in heavily regulated industries such as the financial sector, healthcare, or critical infrastructures, contractual compliance regulations must be precise, comprehensive, and enforceable. At the same time, they must remain practicable and not disproportionately burden the operationalization of the outsourcing relationship.
📜 Basic Compliance Obligations:
•
Precise definition of the applicable regulatory framework with concrete laws, regulations, and industry standards.
•
Explicit obligation to comply with all relevant legal and regulatory requirements.
•
Integration of specific compliance obligations for particularly relevant areas such as data protection, information security, or financial regulation.
•
Specification of minimum standards for internal compliance management systems of the service provider.
•
Obligation to proactively inform about compliance-relevant incidents, official inquiries, and investigations.
🔍 Control and Verification Rights:
•
Establishment of comprehensive information, inspection, and audit rights for compliance monitoring.
•
Specification of regular compliance reporting obligations with standardized formats and contents.
•
Integration of certification requirements as objective compliance evidence (e.g., ISO certifications, SOC reports).
•
Agreement on self-assessments and internal control evidence from the service provider.
•
Regulation of on-site inspections and audits by the outsourcing company or commissioned third parties.
🧪 Regulatory Audits and Authority Access:
•
Explicit permission for regulatory audits and inspections by competent supervisory authorities.
•
Obligation to fully cooperate with official investigations and inquiries.
•
Specification of concrete support obligations for regulatory audits, including resource provision.
•
Regulations for coordination of parallel audits by multiple authorities or instances.
•
Agreement on direct information rights for supervisory authorities vis-à-vis the service provider.
🚨 Escalation and Consequences for Compliance Violations:
•
Implementation of a graduated escalation procedure for compliance violations of different severity levels.
•
Specification of concrete mitigation and remediation obligations for compliance deficiencies.
•
Definition of specific consequences up to special termination rights for serious violations.
•
Agreement on compensation and indemnification obligations for compliance-related damages and sanctions.
•
Implementation of reporting and documentation obligations for compliance incidents and remedial measures.
🔄 Adaptability to Regulatory Changes:
•
Obligation to continuously monitor regulatory developments in the relevant environment.
•
Establishment of structured change management for implementing new regulatory requirements.
•
Specification of responsibilities and cost allocation for compliance-related adjustments.
•
Integration of mechanisms for rapid implementation of urgent regulatory changes.
•
Regulations for conflict resolution in case of different interpretation of new regulatory requirements.
How do you integrate sustainability aspects into outsourcing contracts?
Integrating sustainability aspects into outsourcing contracts is gaining increasing importance through regulatory requirements such as the EU Taxonomy, the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), and supply chain-based due diligence obligations. Companies must ensure that outsourced activities do not jeopardize their own sustainability goals and commitments. A systematic contractual approach to integrating Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) aspects protects against risks and creates opportunities for value creation and innovation.
🌱 Basic ESG Obligations and Standards:
•
Implementation of explicit obligations to comply with environmental, social, and governance standards.
•
Integration of industry-specific sustainability standards and certifications as contractual minimum requirements.
•
Specification of concrete environmental goals such as CO 2 reduction, energy efficiency, or resource conservation with measurable indicators.
•
Agreement on social standards regarding working conditions, human rights, and diversity throughout the supply chain.
•
Implementation of requirements for sustainable procurement and responsible supply chain design.
📊 Monitoring, Reporting, and Transparency:
•
Establishment of structured ESG reporting with defined metrics, formats, and reporting intervals.
•
Specification of verification and audit mechanisms for sustainability-related information and metrics.
•
Integration of transparency requirements for disclosure of sustainability risks and incidents.
•
Development of specific KPIs for continuous measurement and improvement of sustainability performance.
•
Agreement on certification requirements and external validations of sustainability reports.
🎯 Incentive Systems and Performance Management:
•
Implementation of incentive systems for achieving or exceeding sustainability goals.
•
Integration of sustainability KPIs into the commercial model with bonus-malus mechanisms.
•
Development of innovation incentives for sustainability-related improvements and solutions.
•
Specification of consequences for failure to achieve sustainability goals or violation of ESG standards.
•
Design of forward-looking contract models that promote continuous improvement of sustainability performance.
⚖ ️ Compliance and Risk Mitigation:
•
Implementation of specific audit and control rights for sustainability-related aspects of the outsourcing.
•
Specification of liability and indemnification regulations for ESG-related violations and their consequences.
•
Integration of special termination rights for serious violations of central sustainability commitments.
•
Development of contractual mechanisms to protect against reputational and compliance risks.
•
Agreement on mitigation and remediation obligations for sustainability violations or incidents.
🤝 Cooperation and Continuous Improvement:
•
Establishment of joint committees and processes for managing sustainability-related aspects of the outsourcing.
•
Implementation of knowledge exchange and best practice sharing mechanisms in the sustainability area.
•
Development of joint innovation initiatives to improve sustainability performance.
•
Specification of adjustment mechanisms for flexible response to new sustainability challenges and opportunities.
•
Integration of stakeholder engagement processes to consider external perspectives and requirements.
What elements are essential for legally compliant outsourcing contracts?
Legally compliant outsourcing contracts must contain numerous specific elements to fulfill both regulatory requirements and adequately protect business interests. The particular challenge lies in combining legal precision with practical applicability. A professionally designed outsourcing contract considers not only current legal requirements but also anticipates potential risks and developments in the business relationship. The following core elements are indispensable and should be elaborated with particular care in every outsourcing contract.
📋 Precise Service Description:
•
Detailed, unambiguous definition of the scope of services with clear delineation of responsibilities for both parties.
•
Concrete description of deliverables, work results, and expected quality standards.
•
Specification of handover and acceptance processes with specific criteria and timelines.
•
Clear regulations on the involvement of subcontractors and their responsibilities.
•
Defined processes for service changes and adjustments during the contract term.
⚖ ️ Compliance and Regulatory Requirements:
•
Integration of all regulatory requirements relevant to the specific industry (e.g., MaRisk, BAIT, DORA).
•
Specification of control, access, and audit rights of the outsourcing company and supervisory authorities.
•
Explicit obligations to comply with data protection regulations with concrete technical and organizational measures.
•
Regulations on information security with minimum standards and certification requirements.
•
Obligation to cooperate with official inquiries and supervisory audits.
📊 Service Level Agreements (SLAs):
•
Definition of measurable, relevant performance indicators with clear metrics and target values.
•
Specification of measurement procedures, measurement intervals, and reporting formats for performance monitoring.
•
Implementation of a graduated escalation process for SLA violations with specific contact persons and time specifications.
•
Clear consequences for non-compliance, from contractual penalties to extraordinary termination rights.
•
Incentive mechanisms for exceeding targets and continuous improvement of service quality.
🔄 Contract Term and Termination Provisions:
•
Clear definition of the contract term with precise regulations on extensions and notice periods.
•
Detailed regulations for ordinary and extraordinary termination rights with specific termination grounds.
•
Comprehensive exit management clauses with regulations on service handover, data migration, and knowledge transfer.
•
Specification of support obligations of the service provider after contract termination with concrete scope and remuneration.
•
Regulations on handling assets, rights, and confidential information after contract end.
💼 Liability and Risk Allocation:
•
Balanced liability regulations with appropriate liability limitations and exclusions.
•
Concrete regulations on insurance obligations of the service provider with minimum coverage amounts and proof obligations.
•
Precise indemnification clauses for third-party claims, particularly for intellectual property violations or data protection breaches.
•
Clear allocation of responsibilities in case of data loss, security incidents, or business interruptions.
•
Specific regulations for force majeure events with notification obligations and mitigation measures.
How do you develop a customized contract structure for different outsourcing scenarios?
Developing customized contract structures for outsourcing requires a systematic, risk-focused approach that considers the specific characteristics and requirements of each outsourcing scenario. Unlike standard contracts, this involves precisely aligning contractual provisions with the specific operational, legal, and strategic circumstances of the respective outsourcing. This customized approach forms the foundation for a successful, legally compliant, and value-creating outsourcing relationship.
🔍 Systematic Analysis Phase:
•
Conducting a comprehensive risk analysis as the basis for the contract structure with identification of specific risk areas of the outsourcing.
•
Evaluation of regulatory requirements for the specific outsourcing depending on industry, criticality, and data categories.
•
Analysis of the strategic importance of the outsourcing for the company and derivation of corresponding contractual protection mechanisms.
•
Assessment of operational requirements for service delivery, including integration into existing processes and systems.
•
Evaluation of market position and negotiating power of both parties as a basis for realistic contract negotiation goals.
📑 Modular Contract Architecture:
•
Development of a multi-layered contract structure with master agreement and specific service schedules or annexes.
•
Implementation of a Master Service Agreement (MSA) for overarching regulations such as governance, compliance, and legal principles.
•
Creation of specific Service Schedules or Statements of Work (SoW) for detailed service descriptions of individual outsourcing areas.
•
Integration of dedicated annexes for cross-cutting topics such as data protection, information security, or business continuity.
•
Development of customized SLA annexes with service-specific metrics, measurement procedures, and consequences.
⚖ ️ Differentiation by Outsourcing Types:
•
IT Outsourcing: Focus on technical specifications, interface definitions, change management, and technology evolution.
•
Business Process Outsourcing: Emphasis on end-to-end process continuity, capacity flexibility, and cultural aspects.
•
Critical Core Functions: Implementation of particularly robust control, monitoring, and exit mechanisms according to regulatory requirements.
•
Cloud Services: Integration of cloud-specific aspects such as multi-tenancy, data localization, and continuous updates/upgrades.
•
Nearshore/Offshore Scenarios: Consideration of international legal issues, cultural differences, and special communication structures.
🔄 Flexibility Mechanisms and Scalability:
•
Implementation of structured change request processes with defined decision paths and approval levels.
•
Integration of benchmarking and market testing clauses for continuous competitiveness review.
•
Development of contract adjustment mechanisms for technological developments, business changes, or regulatory modifications.
•
Specification of innovation obligations and continuous improvement processes with concrete goals and incentives.
•
Implementation of scaling mechanisms for service scope, volume, and capacities.
🤝 Practical Implementation and Governance:
•
Development of a Contract Playbook with standardized formulations, fallback positions, and negotiation guidelines.
•
Establishment of a clearly defined governance framework with roles, responsibilities, and communication structures.
•
Integration of mechanisms for continuous contract optimization and adjustment over the lifecycle.
•
Establishment of a structured documentation system with clear version control and change tracking.
•
Development of compliance checklists to ensure complete consideration of all regulatory requirements.
What legal specifics must be considered when designing cloud service contracts?
Designing cloud service contracts requires special legal attention, as traditional outsourcing contract patterns often do not adequately address the specific characteristics and risks of cloud services. The standardization of cloud offerings, the multi-tier service provider structure, data and compliance issues, and continuous update cycles present special challenges that must be specifically addressed in contract design. Professional cloud contract design considers these specifics and creates a framework that provides both legal certainty and the necessary flexibility to utilize cloud advantages.
🔄 Handling Standard Contracts and Limited Negotiating Power:
•
Development of risk-focused prioritization for contract negotiations, as cloud providers often show limited willingness to adapt.
•
Identification and focus on indispensable regulatory requirements and critical business risks in negotiations.
•
Targeted supplementation of standard contracts through side letters or additional agreements for company-specific requirements.
•
Use of multi-provider strategies for risk diversification and strengthening negotiating position.
•
Careful documentation of risk assessment and acceptance of remaining risks for non-negotiable clauses.
🌐 Data Localization and International Data Flows:
•
Implementation of precise contractual regulations on data storage location with concrete specifications of data center locations.
•
Integration of appropriate safeguards for international data transfers according to GDPR, such as Standard Contractual Clauses or Binding Corporate Rules.
•
Specification of transparency and information obligations for changes in data processing locations or subcontractors.
•
Consideration of industry-specific data localization requirements, especially in the financial sector, healthcare, and public sector.
•
Implementation of exit strategies in case of legal changes that restrict or make international data transfers impossible.
🔍 Transparency and Control in Multi-Tier Service Provider Relationships:
•
Contractual assurance of appropriate transparency across the entire service provider chain (sub-processors).
•
Specification of approval processes or at least information obligations for changes in the subcontractor structure.
•
Integration of audit and control rights covering the entire service provider chain with practicable implementation mechanisms.
•
Implementation of due diligence obligations of the cloud provider in selecting and monitoring subcontractors.
•
Establishment of clear liability and responsibility regulations for actions and omissions of subcontractors.
📊 Service Continuity and Performance Management:
•
Development of cloud-specific SLAs with metrics such as availability, latency, response times, and recovery times.
•
Implementation of appropriate compensation mechanisms for SLA violations that correspond to actual business impacts.
•
Specification of regulations for planned maintenance windows with appropriate lead times and minimization of operational impacts.
•
Integration of business continuity and disaster recovery obligations with concrete RPOs and RTOs.
•
Agreement on monitoring and reporting mechanisms for continuous monitoring of service quality.
🔒 Information Security and Compliance:
•
Definition of cloud-specific security requirements considering shared responsibility models of different cloud types (IaaS, PaaS, SaaS).
•
Specification of certification requirements (e.g., ISO 27001, SOC 2, C5) and processes for regular compliance verification.
•
Integration of specific incident response obligations with clear reporting channels, deadlines, and support obligations.
•
Agreement on compliance evidence and regular security reports without violating multi-tenant architecture.
•
Development of mechanisms for continuous adaptation of security requirements to new threats and regulatory developments.
How do you design effective service descriptions and SLAs for outsourcing contracts?
Designing precise service descriptions and effective Service Level Agreements (SLAs) is a critical success factor for outsourcing relationships. They form the basis for a common understanding of expected performance, create transparency, and enable objective evaluation of service provider performance. The particular challenge lies in finding a balanced equilibrium: on one hand, requirements must be sufficiently detailed and measurable; on the other hand, they must not become too rigid or unrealistic. A professional approach combines technical precision with business relevance and creates both clarity and the necessary flexibility for long-term successful collaboration.
📋 Basic Principles of Effective Service Descriptions:
•
Focus on clearly defined results and outcomes rather than pure activity descriptions.
•
Use of precise, unambiguous terminology with clear definitions of central terms to avoid interpretation gaps.
•
Structuring into logical, delineated service components with clear interfaces and responsibilities.
•
Balanced level of detail: sufficiently specific for clarity, but not over-specified to maintain necessary flexibility.
•
Integration of graphical elements such as process diagrams, RACI matrices, and interface descriptions to visualize complex relationships.
🎯 Development of Relevant and Measurable SLA Metrics:
•
Identification of business-critical aspects of the outsourced service as the basis for SLA definition.
•
Development of a balanced set of metrics covering various performance dimensions (availability, response time, quality, capacity).
•
Specification of SMART indicators (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) with clear measurement procedures.
•
Differentiation between different priority levels and service levels depending on business criticality.
•
Consideration of the end-to-end perspective with focus on actual business impacts rather than isolated technical metrics.
📊 Monitoring, Reporting, and Governance:
•
Establishment of clear processes and responsibilities for continuous measurement and documentation of SLA metrics.
•
Definition of standardized reporting formats with different levels of detail for various stakeholder groups.
•
Specification of regular review cycles and governance meetings for evaluating performance and addressing deviations.
•
Implementation of a graduated escalation process with clear triggers, contact persons, and timeframes.
•
Establishment of mechanisms for continuous improvement with joint analysis of trends and root causes.
⚖ ️ Consequences and Incentive Structures:
•
Development of a graduated system of consequences for SLA violations, proportional to the severity and frequency of deviations.
•
Implementation of financial penalties that provide an effective incentive without being prohibitive or straining the relationship.
•
Design of service credits as the primary mechanism for moderate SLA violations with direct offset against invoices.
•
Integration of earn-back mechanisms that allow remediation through exceeded SLAs in subsequent periods.
•
Development of positive incentive systems for exceeding targets or continuous improvement of service quality.
🔄 Flexibility and Scalability:
•
Implementation of a structured SLA review process with defined intervals for adaptation to changed business requirements.
•
Specification of mechanisms for rapid adjustment in exceptional business situations or unforeseen events.
•
Integration of continuous improvement goals with gradual increase of requirements over the contract term.
•
Development of mechanisms for benchmarking against market standards with optional adjustment obligations.
•
Consideration of the introduction phase with adapted requirements and gradual increase to full service level.
How do you design effective exit strategies in outsourcing contracts?
Designing effective exit strategies is a critical component of professional outsourcing contracts. A well-thought-out exit strategy minimizes risks and costs when terminating the outsourcing relationship and enables a smooth transition to alternative solutions.
🔄 Comprehensive Exit Scenarios and Planning:
•
Differentiated consideration of various exit scenarios: regular contract termination, early termination, force majeure, insolvency of the service provider.
•
Development of a structured exit plan with clearly defined phases, milestones, and responsibilities.
•
Specification of early trigger points and warning signals that initiate exit preparations.
•
Integration of exit impact assessments to evaluate operational, financial, and regulatory impacts.
•
Establishment of an exit governance model with clear decision paths and escalation mechanisms.
📦 Data and Asset Migration:
•
Precise definition of data extraction and migration processes with concrete formats and handover points.
•
Specification of clear ownership rights and usage rights for data, software, and documentation.
•
Obligation of the service provider to provide structured data in standardized formats.
•
Definition of data quality standards for migration with validation processes.
•
Regulations on secure deletion of data after successful migration with corresponding proof obligations.
🧠 Knowledge Transfer and Know-how Preservation:
•
Establishment of continuous knowledge transfer processes throughout the entire contract term.
•
Contractual obligation for comprehensive documentation of all processes, systems, and configurations.
•
Specification of training and onboarding obligations for successor teams.
•
Regulations on availability and participation of key personnel during the transition phase.
•
Development of knowledge management systems for structured capture of knowledge.
What role do liability provisions play in outsourcing contracts?
Liability provisions in outsourcing contracts form a central component of contractual risk allocation and are crucial for the viability of the outsourcing relationship. A differentiated, risk-appropriate liability design is clearly superior to a blanket approach.
⚖ ️ Basic Structures of Contractual Liability Concepts:
•
Development of a differentiated liability concept with graduated regimes for different scenarios.
•
Precise definition of liability triggers and claim prerequisites for various contract risks.
•
Implementation of separate liability regulations for particularly damage-prone areas.
•
Specification of clear burden of proof distributions and proof obligations when asserting claims.
•
Establishment of a graduated escalation and conflict resolution mechanism for liability cases.
🛡 ️ Differentiated Liability Limitations and Exclusions:
•
Implementation of appropriate, risk-adequate liability limitations based on economic significance.
•
Differentiation between different types of damage with different liability limits.
•
Specification of specific exceptions to liability limitations for particularly serious cases.
•
Development of area-specific liability limits for different service components.
•
Implementation of deductibles and co-payments to promote risk prevention.
📊 Insurance and Financial Security Mechanisms:
•
Specification of concrete insurance obligations of the service provider with minimum coverage amounts.
•
Implementation of proof obligations for insurance coverage with regular reviews.
•
Integration of direct claims against the service provider's insurers.
•
Development of alternative security mechanisms such as bank guarantees or escrow accounts.
•
Specification of notification obligations for changes in insurance coverage.
How do you integrate information security requirements into outsourcing contracts?
Integrating information security requirements into outsourcing contracts is a critical success factor for secure outsourcing relationships in light of increasing cybersecurity risks. An effective contractual information security framework must address both current and future threats.
🔒 Basic Security Architecture and Governance:
•
Development of a comprehensive Information Security Requirements Catalog as a binding contractual basis.
•
Precise definition of security responsibilities in a RACI model.
•
Implementation of a security governance framework with defined roles and escalation paths.
•
Specification of quantifiable security metrics for objective measurement of security level.
•
Establishment of regular security review meetings for continuous monitoring.
🔍 Risk Management and Compliance Requirements:
•
Implementation of a continuous, risk-based security assessment process.
•
Obligation to comply with relevant security standards such as ISO 27001 or NIST.
•
Specification of specific requirements for compliance with industry-specific regulations.
•
Integration of requirements for supply chain security management.
•
Obligation to continuously monitor regulatory changes in the security area.
🛡 ️ Technical Security Measures and Controls:
•
Detailed specification of minimum requirements for technical protective measures.
•
Specification of concrete requirements for detective controls such as security monitoring.
•
Definition of requirements for reactive security measures such as incident response.
•
Specification of security requirements for different system environments.
•
Integration of specific security requirements for modern technologies such as cloud services.
How can innovation incentives be anchored in long-term outsourcing contracts?
Anchoring effective innovation incentives in long-term outsourcing contracts is a central challenge of modern contract design. A well-thought-out contractual innovation framework creates the foundation for a future-proof outsourcing relationship that fulfills both current and future requirements.
🎯 Strategic Innovation Goals and Governance:
•
Establishment of a dedicated Innovation Framework with clear definitions and responsibilities.
•
Implementation of a Joint Innovation Committee with defined decision-making authority.
•
Development of a joint Innovation Roadmap with short- and long-term goals.
•
Specification of Innovation KPIs for objective evaluation of innovation progress.
•
Integration of market and technology radar processes to identify innovation trends.
💰 Commercial Incentive Structures for Innovation:
•
Implementation of a gain-sharing model for demonstrable efficiency improvements through innovations.
•
Development of an Innovation Fund with dedicated budget for pilot projects.
•
Integration of Innovation KPIs into the commercial model with bonus-malus mechanisms.
•
Design of flexible pricing models for innovative services with success-based remuneration.
•
Implementation of open book approaches for innovation initiatives with transparent cost evaluation.
🚀 Processes and Methods for Systematic Innovation:
•
Establishment of a structured Innovation Process from idea generation to implementation.
•
Specification of agile development methods for innovation initiatives with iterative feedback loops.
•
Integration of regular Innovation Workshops and design thinking sessions.
•
Implementation of proof-of-concept projects with simplified approval processes.
•
Development of structured knowledge management for innovations with documentation of best practices.
Success Stories
Discover how we support companies in their digital transformation
Generative KI in der Fertigung
Bosch
KI-Prozessoptimierung für bessere Produktionseffizienz
Fallstudie
Ergebnisse
Reduzierung der Implementierungszeit von AI-Anwendungen auf wenige Wochen
Verbesserung der Produktqualität durch frühzeitige Fehlererkennung
Steigerung der Effizienz in der Fertigung durch reduzierte Downtime
AI Automatisierung in der Produktion
Festo
Intelligente Vernetzung für zukunftsfähige Produktionssysteme
Fallstudie
Ergebnisse
Verbesserung der Produktionsgeschwindigkeit und Flexibilität
Reduzierung der Herstellungskosten durch effizientere Ressourcennutzung
Erhöhung der Kundenzufriedenheit durch personalisierte Produkte
KI-gestützte Fertigungsoptimierung
Siemens
Smarte Fertigungslösungen für maximale Wertschöpfung
Fallstudie
Ergebnisse
Erhebliche Steigerung der Produktionsleistung
Reduzierung von Downtime und Produktionskosten
Verbesserung der Nachhaltigkeit durch effizientere Ressourcennutzung
Digitalisierung im Stahlhandel
Klöckner & Co
Digitalisierung im Stahlhandel
Fallstudie
Ergebnisse
Über 2 Milliarden Euro Umsatz jährlich über digitale Kanäle
Ziel, bis 2022 60% des Umsatzes online zu erzielen
Verbesserung der Kundenzufriedenheit durch automatisierte Prozesse
Let's
Work Together!
Is your organization ready for the next step into the digital future? Contact us for a personal consultation.
Your strategic success starts here
Our clients trust our expertise in digital transformation, compliance, and risk management
Ready for the next step?
Schedule a strategic consultation with our experts now
30 Minutes • Non-binding • Immediately available
For optimal preparation of your strategy session:
Your strategic goals and challenges
Desired business outcomes and ROI expectations
Current compliance and risk situation
Stakeholders and decision-makers in the project
Prefer direct contact?
Direct hotline for decision-makers
Strategic inquiries via email
Detailed Project Inquiry
For complex inquiries or if you want to provide specific information in advance
